From Third Date Movie to $60 Million Candy Empire: The Sugarfina Story

What happens when a movie date sparks a business idea worth millions? For Rosie O'Neill and Josh Resnick, watching Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory on their third date led to a simple question that would change their lives: Why doesn't a candy store for adults exist?

That question, asked in 2010, became Sugarfina—a luxury candy boutique that would grow from a $60,000 combined investment into a company that raised $60 million and expanded to dozens of locations worldwide. The journey offers powerful lessons for entrepreneurs about sacrifice, scaling, and the importance of knowing when to ask for help.

A Match Made on Match.com

O'Neill and Resnick's story begins like many modern romances—online. They met on Match.com in 2010 and connected immediately. But unlike most couples, their early dates weren't just about getting to know each other. They were planting the seeds of a business empire.

During that fateful third date screening of the classic Gene Wilder film, they found themselves captivated not just by the movie but by a gap in the market. Candy stores existed, sure—but they were designed for children. Where could adults go for premium, artisanal confections presented with sophistication?

Both O'Neill and Resnick brought impressive credentials to the table. O'Neill had spent seven years at Mattel as Director of Marketing for Barbie, managing a team of ten talented creatives. Resnick had founded Pandemic Studios, a video game development company he grew into a global innovator before selling it to Electronic Arts in 2008 for a sum rumored to be in the nine-figure range.

They had the skills. They had the resources. And now, they had the idea.

The $30,000 Leap of Faith

In May 2012, O'Neill and Resnick decided to turn their date-night musings into reality. Each invested $30,000 of their personal savings—a total of $60,000 to launch Sugarfina.

For O'Neill, this meant a complete lifestyle overhaul. She left her comfortable corporate position at Mattel and made immediate, dramatic changes:

• Downsized from a house to a studio apartment
• Traded her luxury car for a more economical model
• Limited herself to a $100-per-week personal budget
• Eliminated virtually all disposable income

The e-commerce store launched in July 2012, just two months after development began. But perhaps the most significant sacrifice was time itself. O'Neill went from a standard Monday-to-Friday schedule to working approximately 100-hour weeks.

"I felt I needed to invest every spare moment into the business," O'Neill has explained, describing how she and Resnick handled everything themselves in the early days.

Doing Everything Themselves

The first few months of Sugarfina tested O'Neill's versatility in ways her corporate career never had. Without a team to rely on, she and Resnick became a two-person operation handling every aspect of the business:

• Packing candy into cubes and boxes for e-commerce orders
• Handwriting personal notes to customers
• Answering customer service calls directly on her cell phone
• Managing fulfillment and logistics
• Strategic planning and business development

O'Neill also taught herself new skills out of necessity. With no budget for designers, she learned Adobe Illustrator and Photoshop to create the website and packaging herself. This hands-on approach meant she understood every aspect of the business intimately—knowledge that would prove invaluable as Sugarfina scaled.

By October 2012, the volume had grown enough that they hired their first team members. But those initial months of doing everything themselves established a culture of hard work and attention to detail that would define the brand.

The Division of Labor

As Sugarfina grew, O'Neill and Resnick naturally divided responsibilities according to their strengths. O'Neill, with her Mattel background, handled the creative side: marketing, store design, packaging design, and brand development. Her keen attention to detail shaped Sugarfina's distinctive aesthetic—the signature blue-and-white color scheme, the elegant Candy Bento Boxes, the premium presentation that made candy feel like a luxury gift.

Resnick, drawing on his experience scaling Pandemic Studios, managed operations, facilities, finance, HR, and legal matters. This clear division allowed each founder to focus on their areas of expertise while trusting their partner to handle the rest.

From Online to Brick-and-Mortar

The first physical Sugarfina boutique opened in Beverly Hills in November 2013, just over a year after the e-commerce launch. The retail expansion proved that luxury candy had mainstream appeal. Customers weren't just buying candy—they were buying an experience.

The concept resonated particularly well with corporate gifting, wedding favors, and holiday presents. Sugarfina's curated collections featuring champagne gummy bears, rosé-infused gummies, and single malt scotch cordials offered something no traditional candy store could: adult sophistication in a confection.

Over the following years, Sugarfina expanded aggressively. Partnerships with Nordstrom brought shop-in-shop locations to department stores across the country. Standalone boutiques opened in prime retail locations. By 2018, the company had raised $60 million from investors—including Goldman Sachs and even Bono from U2.

The Challenges of Scaling

But rapid growth brought new challenges. As O'Neill has reflected, the nature of her work transformed completely as Sugarfina scaled. Early on, the challenge was doing everything herself. Later, the challenge became "you can't solve it yourself. You need to be a good leader and a great attractor of talent."

This transition from doer to leader is one of the most difficult shifts an entrepreneur faces. The skills that make someone excellent at launching a company—willingness to do every task, attention to every detail, personal investment in every decision—can become liabilities when managing a larger organization.

O'Neill learned to delegate, to trust her team, and to focus on strategic leadership rather than tactical execution. These lessons came through experience, sometimes painfully.

The Bankruptcy and Rebirth

Sugarfina's story took a dramatic turn in September 2019 when the company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The factors were complex: a challenging retail environment, particularly in mall locations where many boutiques were situated; difficulties controlling margins; and uncertainty in international partnerships.

Despite revenues doubling year-over-year between 2012 and 2017, the company reported mounting losses—$4.8 million in 2016, $7.3 million in 2017, and $17.9 million in 2018. The costs of aggressive expansion had outpaced profitability.

In November 2019, Bristol Luxury Group acquired Sugarfina's assets for $15.1 million. The new ownership faced immediate challenges, including inventory shortages that affected holiday sales and fewer retail locations after unprofitable leases were shed during bankruptcy.

But the brand survived. Under new leadership, Sugarfina continues to operate, selling its signature luxury candies and maintaining the aesthetic vision O'Neill and Resnick created.

Lessons for Entrepreneurs

The Sugarfina story—both its successes and its struggles—offers valuable insights for anyone building a business:

1. Be Willing to Sacrifice Comfort

O'Neill didn't just reduce her expenses; she fundamentally restructured her life around the business. The studio apartment, the budget car, the $100 weekly allowance—these weren't just cost-cutting measures. They were signals of commitment, both to herself and to the business.

For four years, neither founder took a salary. This extended runway allowed them to reinvest every dollar into growth.

2. Learn New Skills When Necessary

Rather than waiting until she could afford to hire designers, O'Neill taught herself Illustrator and Photoshop. This self-sufficiency accelerated Sugarfina's launch and gave O'Neill deep understanding of the brand's visual identity.

Entrepreneurs who can acquire new skills quickly—even imperfectly—have a significant advantage over those who wait for perfect resources.

3. Know When to Transition from Doer to Leader

The skills that launch a company differ from those required to scale it. O'Neill recognized that she needed to become "a good leader and a great attractor of talent" rather than trying to do everything herself.

This transition is uncomfortable. It requires trusting others with work you've always controlled. But it's essential for growth.

4. Growth Has Costs

Sugarfina's aggressive expansion contributed to its financial difficulties. Rapid scaling requires capital, and that capital has to come from somewhere—either profits or investors. When growth outpaces profitability, even successful brands can find themselves in trouble.

This doesn't mean you shouldn't pursue growth. It means you should understand its true costs and plan accordingly.

5. A Brand Can Outlive Its Original Structure

Even after bankruptcy, Sugarfina continues. The brand, the aesthetic, the product lines—these assets had value independent of the original company's financial structure. For entrepreneurs, this is a reminder that building a strong brand creates lasting value, even if the business journey takes unexpected turns.

The Long-Term Perspective

Despite Sugarfina's financial challenges, O'Neill emerged with valuable lessons and habits. She has spoken about maintaining the lean lifestyle practices she developed during the startup years, valuing time with loved ones and personal wellness over material consumption.

The entrepreneurial journey changed her relationship with money and success. The experience of building something from nothing—of packing candy into boxes at 2 AM, of answering customer calls on her personal cell phone, of watching her vision become reality in a Beverly Hills storefront—created rewards that transcended the financial outcome.

Building Something Sweet

Sugarfina proved that there was indeed a market for adult candy—for premium confections presented with elegance and sophistication. The concept O'Neill and Resnick dreamed up on their third date resonated with millions of customers who wanted to indulge their sweet tooth without feeling childish.

The business journey wasn't smooth. There were years of sacrifice, moments of crisis, and ultimately a bankruptcy that transferred ownership to new hands. But the brand endures, and the lessons from building it remain valuable for anyone considering their own entrepreneurial leap.

Sometimes the best business ideas come from the simplest questions. Why doesn't this exist? Who would want it? Could I be the one to create it?

O'Neill and Resnick asked those questions over a movie on their third date. Their answer built a candy empire.

Keep Your Finances Organized from Day One

Whether you're launching a luxury candy brand or any other venture, maintaining clear financial records is essential for understanding your margins, tracking growth, and making informed decisions. Beancount.io offers plain-text accounting that gives you complete transparency and control over your financial data—no black boxes, no vendor lock-in. Get started for free and see why developers and finance professionals are choosing plain-text accounting for their businesses.