Imagine you are preparing to sell the business you spent a decade building, and two credentialed appraisers hand you two different numbers: USD 900,000 from one, USD 1,600,000 from the other. Neither made an arithmetic error. They simply answered different questions. One priced your profits; the other priced your property. If you ever sell, buy, bring in a partner, or settle an estate, you need to know which question governs your situation — because anchoring the negotiation to the wrong one can cost you a third of the deal before the first offer arrives.
Professional valuation standards recognize exactly three approaches to value: the income approach, the market approach, and the asset approach. Every credible valuation starts from that trio, considers all three, and selects the one that best fits the company and the purpose. This guide explains how each approach works, what buyers actually paid in recent deals, the rule that decides which one governs your business, and the single most common mistake sellers make when they run the numbers themselves.
The Three Approaches in One Picture
The U.S. tax authority states the framework plainly: the three generally accepted valuation approaches are the asset-based approach, the market approach, and the income approach, and the appraiser must consider each before choosing. The AICPA valuation standard and the NACVA professional standards use the same taxonomy. Translated into plain language for an owner:
- Income approach: value the future earnings the business will produce, either by capitalizing a normalized earnings figure or discounting projected cash flows to today.
- Market approach: value the business against prices actually paid for comparable companies, expressed as a multiple of earnings or revenue.
- Asset approach: value the business as the sum of its parts — assets restated to market value, minus liabilities.
Notice that the first two both rest on earnings. That is why owners can usefully collapse the whole decision into one question: will a buyer pay for your profits, or for your property? The rest of this guide answers it.
The Income Approach: Price the Earnings Stream
The income approach treats your company as a machine that manufactures future profit, and asks what a buyer should pay today for that stream. It comes in two forms. Capitalization of earnings takes a single normalized earnings figure — one representative year, adjusted for owner quirks — and divides it by a capitalization rate that reflects risk. Discounted cash flow (DCF) projects several years of cash flow, adds a terminal value for everything beyond the forecast, and discounts the whole stream back to present dollars.
The earnings measure changes with company size, and using the wrong one is the fastest way to misread your own value:
- Seller's discretionary earnings (SDE) is the standard for Main Street businesses, roughly up to USD 5 million in revenue. SDE starts from profit and adds back the owner's full compensation, because the buyer is typically an individual who will step into your seat and earn that salary themselves.
- EBITDA takes over in the lower middle market, roughly USD 5 million to USD 150 million in revenue, where the buyer is a company or investment group that will keep a hired manager in place at a market salary. Owner pay is normalized to that market rate rather than added back in full.
Recasting — normalizing the books before applying any math — is where most do-it-yourself valuations fail. Owner compensation above or below market, personal expenses run through the business, one-time lawsuits or windfalls, and depreciation that reflects tax strategy rather than wear all have to be corrected first. A multiple applied to unadjusted books prices your tax planning, not your business. Every income-approach number in a negotiation traces back to the quality of that cleanup, which is why buyers discount sellers whose records cannot support it.
The Market Approach: Price What Buyers Actually Paid
The market approach skips the theory and asks the empirical question: what did comparable businesses actually sell for? The appraiser finds guideline transactions — completed sales of similar companies — and expresses each as a multiple of earnings. Your value is your normalized earnings times the multiple the market supports. It is the closest thing valuation has to ground truth, because it reflects real money changing hands rather than a model's assumptions.
Recent transaction data shows how steeply the multiple climbs with deal size. For small-business sales, the median multiple was 2.0 times SDE for deals under USD 500,000, 2.8 times from USD 500,000 to USD 1 million, and 3.1 times from USD 1 million to USD 2 million. Crossing into EBITDA territory changes the buyer pool from individuals to institutions: deals from USD 2 million to USD 5 million closed around 4.0 times EBITDA, and lower-middle-market deals from USD 5 million to USD 50 million commanded roughly 5.3 to 6.5 times EBITDA. Across all closed small-business sales, the average cash-flow multiple held near 2.7 times SDE. The pattern is consistent across surveys: bigger, more transferable earnings earn a richer multiple, because the buyer pool deepens and the risk diversifies.
Professionals lean on this approach heavily in practice. More than three-quarters of business appraisers use recast EBITDA multiples — the most-used of any multiples method — and guideline company transactions carry the largest single weight among valuation methods, about one-third of the total. When your banker, your broker, and the buyer's analyst all anchor to comparable deals, knowing your own multiple before the conversation starts is not optional preparation; it is the price of admission.
The market approach has one honest limitation: comparables are never identical. Differences in growth, customer concentration, recurring revenue, and owner dependence all justify adjusting the multiple up or down. A defensible market valuation shows its work — which transactions were selected, why they compare, and what was adjusted — rather than quoting an industry rule of thumb as if it were a price tag.
The Asset Approach: Price What You Own Minus What You Owe
The asset approach ignores earnings entirely and values the business as the market value of everything it owns, minus everything it owes. The appraiser walks the balance sheet line by line and restates each item to current market value: equipment at replacement or auction value rather than depreciated book value, inventory at realizable value, real estate at appraised value, with unrecorded liabilities brought onto the ledger. Two versions matter:
- Adjusted book value (going concern): assets restated at market value assuming the business keeps operating. This is the usual form for asset-heavy companies.
- Liquidation value: what the assets would bring in an orderly or forced wind-down, net of selling costs. This is the true floor beneath every other number in the negotiation.
The trap in taking book value at face value is that depreciation schedules are tax documents, not market evidence. A fleet of well-maintained excavators can be nearly written off on the books yet worth seven figures at auction. The opposite happens too: obsolete inventory carried at cost can be worth pennies on the dollar. An asset approach done properly replaces accounting fiction with market fact, asset by asset.
Keeping that restatement visible in your own records pays off long before a sale. One clean technique is to book market-value adjustments to a dedicated equity account, so your tax-basis books stay intact while the adjusted balance sheet is always one report away:
2026-01-01 open Assets:Equipment
2026-01-01 open Equity:Valuation-Adjustments
2026-11-01 * "Restate delivery van from book value to market value"
Assets:Equipment 18000 USD
Equity:Valuation-AdjustmentsWhen the buyer's analyst asks how you support your asset number, pointing at dated adjustment entries beats pointing at a spreadsheet built the week before the listing. The Beancount documentation covers how to structure accounts like this so your operating books and your valuation view never contaminate each other.
Which Approach Governs Your Business?
The decision rule is older than most businesses being sold today. IRS Revenue Ruling 59-60, still the foundational authority on valuing private companies, holds that for companies selling products or services, earnings may be the most important criterion of value, while for investment or holding companies the appraiser gives the greatest weight to the assets underlying the security. In practice the mapping looks like this:
| Your situation | Primary approach | Secondary check |
|---|---|---|
| Profitable going concern: services, distribution, contracting, retail | Earnings-based | Asset value as the floor |
| Asset-heavy but profitable: equipment rental, trucking, machining | Earnings-based | Asset value, watched closely — it can approach the earnings value |
| Earning below a fair return on assets | Asset-based | Earnings value confirms the shortfall |
| Real-estate or investment holding entity | Asset-based | Income the assets produce |
| Wind-down or liquidation | Asset-based, at liquidation value | None — the floor is the number |
The subtlest row is the third. When a company earns less than a fair return on the assets it employs, the earnings math produces a value below what those assets would bring on their own. At that point no rational seller accepts the earnings number, and the asset approach takes over. The buyer is no longer buying an income stream; they are buying property with a business attached. Recognizing which side of that line you stand on — before the buyer tells you — is the entire game.
The Mistake That Doubles Your Number
The most common valuation error sellers make is also the most expensive: taking an earnings-based value at a market multiple, then adding every asset the business owns on top of it. The vehicles, the equipment, the inventory, all stacked onto the earnings figure as if they were a separate purchase. It feels reasonable — the assets are real, you paid real money for them, and a buyer would spend real money to replace them. But it charges the buyer twice for the same dollar of profit.
An earnings-based value already includes the operating assets. The trucks, the shop, and the inventory are the engine that produces the earnings; a multiple of earnings is the price of that engine's output with the engine included. It is either-or, not both: earnings set the value or assets do, whichever governs, and the table above tells you which camp you are in.
The one asset that can legitimately sit on top is company-owned real estate, because it is a non-operating asset. The business does not have to own its building to earn its profits — it could just as easily lease the same space at a market rent. That is why real property is valued separately and added to, or carved out of, the deal. Equipment is different: the machines a company needs to operate as a going concern cannot be separated from the earnings they produce, so they stay inside the earnings-based value. Confusing the two is exactly how sellers talk themselves into a number no buyer will ever pay.
Two related errors compound the damage. The first is applying a multiple to tax-return net income, which you spent all year legitimately minimizing, and concluding the business is worth little. The second is anchoring to a peak year or an outdated industry rule of thumb instead of normalized, recast earnings. Both are failures of the same input: garbage earnings in, garbage value out.
Run Both Numbers Before Anyone Else Does
The gap between your earnings value and your asset value is information. A wide gap in favor of earnings means buyers are paying for goodwill — the customer relationships, trained workforce, systems, and reputation a buyer cannot buy at auction. A narrow or inverted gap means the market will price your property, and your negotiation should start there. The same company can deserve two different valuations at two different moments: improve margins for two years and the earnings approach rewards you at a multiple, while letting earnings drift as the fleet holds value quietly turns the asset floor into your best argument.
Your next step is concrete. Recast one full year of financials — normalize owner pay, strip one-offs, separate personal expenses — then compute both an earnings-based value at a multiple your deal size supports and an adjusted-book-value floor from market-restated assets. Whichever governs, you will walk into the first buyer conversation knowing what the market will think before the market gets a vote.





