Your Stripe dashboard says MRR grew 8% last month. Your spreadsheet says 3%. An investor asks which number is right, and the uncomfortable answer is that neither one is wrong — Stripe and your spreadsheet simply define MRR differently, counting trials, discounts, refunds, and annual prepayments by different rules. Every SaaS founder hits this moment, and it is the moment subscription analytics tools exist for: one reconciled set of numbers for MRR, churn, LTV, and retention that you can report without footnoting your own math. Three names dominate the shortlist for small teams: Baremetrics, ChartMogul, and ProfitWell Metrics from Paddle. All three compute the same core metrics. They differ in what they cost at your revenue stage, whether they act on churn or only report it, and what else they bundle in.
This post compares the three on the questions that decide the purchase: what each tool really costs from zero to past $10M ARR, which features actually move your net revenue number, how they handle multiple billing systems and switching, and a verdict by situation — including how to book the subscription and any recovered revenue on your own ledger once you buy.
What each tool actually is
Baremetrics is subscription analytics plus revenue operations. Founded in 2013 in the US and owned by Xenon Partners since 2020, it computes the standard metric set — the company counts more than 28 metrics — and then sells the two features that act on churn rather than just reporting it: Recover, an automated failed-payment recovery add-on, and Cancellation Insights, exit surveys that ask cancelling customers why they left. Forecasting and scenario planning arrive on the top tier. Think of Baremetrics as the tool for founders whose churn problem is something they want the software to fight, not just chart. Its heritage is Stripe-first, with Braintree, Chargebee, Recurly, app-store connectors, and accounting integrations alongside.
ChartMogul is subscription analytics plus data normalization plus a CRM. Founded in 2014 in Berlin and still independent, its core pitch is cleaning messy billing data from several systems into one consistent, investor-grade dataset. Every plan, including the free one, ships with industry benchmarks, revenue forecasting, and a native CRM with HubSpot, Salesforce, and Intercom sync — features its rivals sell separately or not at all. What it does not have, at any price, is dunning: if failed payments are eating your growth, ChartMogul will show you the hole with precision and offer no pump. Think of it as the analyst's tool, strongest when revenue arrives through more than one billing system.
ProfitWell Metrics, owned by Paddle since the 2022 acquisition, is subscription analytics as a loss leader. It reports MRR, churn, LTV, ARPU, cohorts, and benchmarks drawn from more than 30,000 subscription companies, and it is free at any revenue with no paid tier of the analytics itself. Paddle funds it to sell adjacent products: Paddle Billing, the merchant-of-record platform, and Paddle Retain, the churn-recovery tooling. Two honest caveats come with the zero price. Dashboards refresh every 3 to 6 hours rather than in real time, and the product's commercial gravity now pulls toward Paddle's own billing stack, so teams on other processors should confirm connector support before committing.
Pricing: three different answers to what free means
Price the tier you will be on in eighteen months, not the tier that gets you through signup, because every vendor here gates price by your revenue and the bill moves as you grow. All figures below are vendor-published 2026 list prices in US dollars, checked against vendor pages and independent comparisons in the second half of 2026; each vendor reprices regularly, so confirm the live page before you budget.
ProfitWell Metrics is the simplest: $0 at any MRR, forever, with no revenue cap. There is no paid analytics tier to graduate into. The monetization sits one step away in Retain and Paddle Billing, whose Retain pricing outside Paddle Billing is unpublished — if recovery tooling is part of your plan, get that quote before treating ProfitWell as permanently free.
ChartMogul is free under $10K MRR (about $120K ARR) with one billing source, a genuinely usable tier covering metric calculation, segmentation, benchmarks, and forecasting. Above it, Starter and Pro scale by ARR band across published boundaries at $500K, $1M, $1.5M, $3M, $5M, $7M, and $10M ARR: Starter runs roughly $59 to $707 per month on monthly billing, Pro roughly $99 to $1,199, with annual billing about 17% cheaper. Two limits matter more than the headline numbers. Starter caps the team at three members, so a five-person team comparing Starter against a rival is comparing the wrong plan — unlimited seats require Pro. And past $10M ARR both Starter and Pro disappear into Enterprise from $19,900 per year, a floor near $1,658 per month that is negotiated upward from there.
Baremetrics prices by ARR-gated plan tier. Launch covers up to $360K ARR at $75 per month, or $49 on annual billing, with a single billing integration. Crossing $360K ARR moves you to Growth at $255 per month ($189 annual) with two integrations, and crossing $3.6M ARR moves you to Scale at $1,152 per month ($749 annual) with unlimited connections. Those are hard gates, so the bill roughly triples at each threshold, and the annual discount near 35% means monthly billing is effectively a penalty rate. The two add-ons each cost $129 per month: Recover and Cancellation Insights. A Growth customer wanting both pays $513 per month on monthly billing — double the plan price — and on Launch the add-ons cost more than the plan itself. One caveat: Baremetrics shuffled its entry packaging during 2026, with some late-2026 vendor pages showing a free tier up to $180K ARR where earlier pages showed a trial only, so verify the current entry before budgeting.
The stage-by-stage picture, in monthly terms:
| Your ARR | Baremetrics | ChartMogul | ProfitWell |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0–$120K | Launch, $49–$75 | Free, $0 | Free, $0 |
| $120K–$360K | Launch, $49–$75 | Starter, lowest band from $59 | Free, $0 |
| $500K–$3.6M | Growth, $189–$255 flat | Starter/Pro mid-bands | Free, $0 |
| $3.6M–$10M | Scale, $749–$1,152 | Starter capped at $707; Pro to $1,199 | Free, $0 |
| Past $10M | Scale, $749–$1,152, no ceiling | Enterprise from $19,900/yr | Free, $0 |
Three takeaways. First, below $120K ARR the paid tools compete against two different flavors of free, and paying for metrics alone at that stage is hard to justify. Second, the $360K–$3.6M middle is genuinely close between the two paid tools — Baremetrics' flat Growth price can beat or lose to your exact ChartMogul band, so get both quotes. Third, the paid curves cross twice: ChartMogul wins from $3.6M to $10M because Starter's $707 cap sits below Scale's $749 floor, then Baremetrics wins past $10M where Scale holds flat and ChartMogul forces Enterprise. None of that arithmetic includes Recover, which can pay for itself — see the next section — and that changes the comparison from sticker prices to net economics.
The features that actually decide the purchase
Core metric parity is real: MRR, ARR, churn, LTV, retention, expansion, contraction, and cohorts come from all three. Decide on what differs.
Failed-payment recovery. A meaningful share of card-billed SaaS churn is involuntary — expired cards, not unhappy customers — and this is the single biggest functional split in the comparison. Baremetrics Recover sends branded dunning emails (seven by default), retries with smart logic, adds SMS, in-app banners, and paywalls, and reports recovered revenue next to your metrics, carrying an ROI guarantee: recover more than your Baremetrics cost or the next month is free. If it claws back even $130 in a month you would otherwise have lost, the add-on is free in net terms. Paddle Retain is the ProfitWell-side equivalent, with automated dunning and cancellation flows, but it is priced for and centered on Paddle Billing. ChartMogul has nothing here. If involuntary churn is your problem, the shortlist is Baremetrics plus Recover or the Paddle stack — ChartMogul at any price cannot do this job, and pairing it with a separate recovery product may cost more than the single-vendor Baremetrics stack.
Cancellation insight. Baremetrics' Cancellation Insights surveys customers at the moment of cancellation, turning "customer churn rose two points" into "twelve customers left over missing SSO." ChartMogul offers churn analytics without the survey layer, and ProfitWell's comparable depth lives in Retain. Teams flying blind on why customers leave should weigh this heavily: a churn rate without reasons is a symptom without a diagnosis.
CRM. ChartMogul's native CRM on every plan, with two-way HubSpot and Salesforce sync on Pro, eliminates a category of spreadsheet reconciliation for sales-assisted SaaS: pipeline and revenue metrics in one tool, no integration project. Neither rival has one. If your reps are few and your motion is self-serve, this is worth little; if demos and pipeline reviews run your week, it is worth real money against a separate CRM seat.
Benchmarks and forecasting. All three benchmark you against other subscription companies, but the packaging differs: ChartMogul includes benchmarks on every plan including free, Baremetrics gates them to Growth and up, and ProfitWell's pool of 30,000-plus companies is the deepest free reference available. Forecasting follows the same pattern — ChartMogul bundles revenue forecasting everywhere, Baremetrics reserves its Forecast+ profit-and-loss, runway, and burn-rate modeling for Scale. Early-stage founders who want credible "are we normal" numbers on day one get them free from two of the three.
Multi-source normalization. If revenue arrives through Stripe plus Paddle plus PayPal, or web plus app stores, the tool's data-modeling depth is the purchase. ChartMogul was founded for this: consolidating fragmented billing into one normalized dataset, with five sources on Pro and fifteen on Enterprise, plus warehouse pushes to Snowflake and BigQuery at the Pro tier. Baremetrics gates connections by plan — one on Launch, two on Growth, unlimited only on Scale — so a company billing through Stripe and the App Store needs Growth for the connections alone, though its app-store connectors are first-class. ProfitWell connects to the major processors but is thinnest here. Map your billing stack before you map prices: the cheapest tool that cannot see all your revenue is the most expensive one.
Freshness. ProfitWell's 3-to-6-hour refresh cadence is fine for weekly reviews and board decks, and wrong for launch-day monitoring or same-day dunning triggers. If you need to watch a pricing change land in real time, that requirement alone narrows the field.
Integrations, migration, and the numbers will not match
Lock-in is low by SaaS standards across all three, because none of them is your system of record — your billing platform is. Connect a new tool and it rebuilds your full metric history from Stripe or Chargebee data, so switching costs no historical MRR. What you do lose is everything the new tool cannot reconstruct: saved segments, custom dashboards, annotations, scheduled email reports, and, most painfully, add-on history. Recover campaign performance and Cancellation Insights survey responses live only in Baremetrics; churned-customer survey data cannot be rebuilt after you leave.
Plan for the trap every switcher hits: the numbers will not match. Each tool applies its own normalization rules to trials, discounts, refunds, annual-contract amortization, and currency conversion, so the same Stripe account produces slightly different MRR in each product. Neither figure is wrong — Paddle-family churn counted at period end versus Stripe counting at cancellation is the same phenomenon one level down. But if you have reported one tool's MRR to investors for two years, switching midstream introduces a discontinuity you will have to footnote. Pick early, or switch at a clean fiscal-year boundary, and never present figures from two tools side by side without naming which normalization produced each.
Exportability also differs where it hurts. ChartMogul pushes normalized metrics to your own warehouse starting at Pro, which means your metrics data lives in your Snowflake or BigQuery at mid-tier prices. Baremetrics' analytics API arrives only on Scale. If owning your metrics data matters — for custom board reporting, for diligence data rooms, for leaving cleanly later — that asymmetry is worth more than a small monthly price gap.
Verdict: pick by situation, not by feature count
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Under $10K MRR, one billing system | ProfitWell or ChartMogul free | Credible metrics at $0; ChartMogul adds CRM and forecasting, ProfitWell never expires by revenue |
| Failed payments are eating growth | Baremetrics plus Recover | The only analytics-plus-dunning stack here with published pricing; the ROI guarantee bounds the risk |
| Billing through 2 or more systems | ChartMogul Pro | Five sources, normalization as the core product, warehouse export included |
| Sales-assisted SaaS, CRM plus metrics in one | ChartMogul | Native CRM on every plan; two-way sync on Pro |
| On Paddle Billing already | ProfitWell plus Retain | Metrics free, recovery native to the stack you already run |
| Mobile app subscriptions in the mix | Baremetrics | First-class App Store and Google Play connectors |
| Past $10M ARR, cost-sensitive | Baremetrics Scale | Flat $749–$1,152 with no ARR ceiling versus Enterprise from $19,900 per year |
Two anti-recommendations sharpen the picture. Do not buy Baremetrics under $120K ARR to get metrics alone — you would pay for what two rivals give away — unless Recover is the actual purchase and analytics is the bonus. And do not buy ChartMogul if your churn problem is failed payments, if your team of four-plus priced Starter without noticing its three-seat cap, or if you will cross $10M ARR on a budget that has no room for a $19,900 floor.
Booking the subscription and the revenue it recovers
Whichever tool you pick, two bookkeeping habits keep the analytics honest. First, the subscription itself is operating software expense, not cost of goods sold — it does not scale with each unit you deliver — so book it under software alongside your other tooling. Second, revenue that dunning recovers is subscription revenue, not a negative expense: netting it against the Recover fee understates both your top line and your software spend, and the distortion compounds exactly when recovery works best. Tag recovered invoices separately so the month-end close can show what the tool earned, not just what it cost. Reconcile the tool's MRR against your ledger monthly; a dashboard that says $80,000 while your books say otherwise is a data-hygiene problem, and the fix is pipeline discipline in your billing data, not a different vendor. The Beancount documentation covers how double-entry tracking keeps each side of that reconciliation honest, and a dashboard like Fava can chart the ledger side next to the tool's exports.
A minimal ledger sketch for one month looks like this:
2026-01-01 open Assets:Checking USD
2026-01-01 open Expenses:Software:Analytics USD
2026-01-01 open Income:Subscriptions USD
2026-01-01 open Income:Subscriptions:Recovered USD
2026-11-01 * "ChartMogul" "Starter plan, November"
Expenses:Software:Analytics 69.00 USD
Assets:Checking
2026-11-12 * "Stripe" "Recovered failed payment, invoice 1042"
Assets:Checking 499.00 USD
Income:Subscriptions:RecoveredThis week, run the decision as a checklist rather than a debate: confirm your ARR band and billing-source count, pull one month of failed-payment losses from Stripe to size the Recover question in dollars, verify the live pricing page for your exact band, and connect exactly one tool before month-end so next month's MRR has a single definition. The failure mode is not picking the wrong one of the three — all are mature, credible products. It is paying for metrics you could have free, or discovering at $10.1M ARR that your analytics bill just multiplied.




